three written pieces = two short stories and one novel
of Sci-Fi and/or horror fantasy
about human fantasy
JORDEN ÄR EN SAGA ["Planet Earth is A Fairytale"]
by Sven Christer Swahn
Sweden 2004
(in nova sci-fi magazine)
+3 Language
-1 Characters
+1 Thrill
+1 Humour
+3 Fantasy
+2 Reality
+3 Whole Composition
= +12
SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES
by Ray Bradbury
USA 1962
through audio book read by Kevin Foley
+1 Language
+2 Characters
0 Thrill
+1 Humour
+2 Fantasy
+1 Reality
-1 Whole Composition
= +6
THE SILVER KEY
by H.P. Lovecraft
USA 1926
translated to swedish (in mitrania sci-fi magazine)
+1 Language
-2 Characters
-2 Thrill
-3 Humour
+3 Fantasy
+2 Reality
-2 Whole Composition
= -3
I review each aspect through scale -3, -2, -1, 0, +1, +2, +3
Total possible is +21 for the very most promising
while -21 can still be a story worth reading
Rather than judging I'm just trying to see the dynamics
wWw
No comments:
Post a Comment